Carol of Casey’s Pizza

Reviews

• Nichole E.

  star star star star star 9 November 2026

  We've tried a few pizzarias here in Penn Hills and this is the best place around. We order pizza, subs, etc. every week and have been disappointed by other places. So far, Carol of Casey's does a great job every time.

• Sexy S.

  star star star star star 23 October 2026

  By the time I was done reading all the reviews I definitely didn't want to order but something told me to give them a try. The staff was very polite and welcoming. I ordered a half of a steak hoagie and the S#%* was  everything down to the mayo tasted fresh... WAIT BUT IT WAS ONLY 5.15 BEST STEAK HOAGIE IN PENNHILLS

• Mike S.

  star star star star star_border 22 October 2026

  One of the best pizza shops in Penn Hills the pizza and Stromboli are excellent most of the time. The only problem is they are not consistent enough. I've had a few issues with the food over the years and delivery service has been so terrible I only pickup now. One time it took 2.5 hours for delivery and no it wasn't like Super Bowl Sunday or anything just a normal day. All that said one of my go to spots you have to give them a shot

• David S.

  star star star star star_border 18 October 2026

  After reading the reviews for this place I initially regretted placing an order. When I arrived to pick up lunch, my pizza was coming out of the oven! The cook realized that the crust was charred and insisted that he made us another one. However, I was on lunch break so I told him I really couldn't wait (plus as you can see from the picture it is not burnt THAT bad). He then insisted that we take our order free of charge and also threw in some fried dough and bread sticks on the house!
  
  To me, that is exceptional customer service. Most places would've boxed up the pizza the way it was and still charge us for it. I loved the pizza and the fries dough was amazing. Wasn't the best pizza I've ever had but I would definitely get it again. Didn't really care for the breadsticks, but hey they were free. I am proud to write this yelp review and hope that future potential customers disregard the other reviews and give this place a definite shot!

• Meg F.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 13 October 2026

  Mediocre would be too generous. Ordered 2 Stromboli, a veggie, and a pepperoni & sausage. My boyfriend was happy with his meat pocket, but the veggie Stromboli I ordered was sickening. Not only was it incredibly soggy, but the mushrooms were raw & the green peppers tasted canned.... The sauce was beyond bland, and probably from a jar. Thank goodness for the small salad I also got. A chunk of anemic iceberg lettuce with a couple thin cucumber pieces and maybe a quarter of a tomato slice was the highlight here. Also I wonder if they buy Papa John's dough and try to pass it off? Can't wait to order again... NOT